Innumerable times we have heard that the rate of plagiarism
is the highest among our authors and researchers. Does this mean we are more prone
to copying and cheating or is it a simple demonstration of lack of awareness of
the rules? Most of us would have to accept it is the second reason.
There are many rules to keep in mind while
preparing a scientific manuscript. One notable yet
often forgotten rule is work that has a copy right should not be
duplicated exactly, it should either be paraphrased
or placed in quotation marks along with the author's name.
Any text should be considered to represent two different,
independent entities. One is the information that it conveys, and the other is
the manner in which it conveys the information. The information can be
presented with a citation. The manner in
which it was conveyed or the exact sentence / phrase can not be used without
using a quotation mark. The information conveyed by anyone even if discovered
by them is essentially from a universal pool of knowledge that anyone could
have found and thus a citation merely naming the person/s who found or
presented them is sufficient. The exact manner in which information is
presented by anyone is their true intellectual property since no other
person could have access to that thought process.
The following example may help make the concept
more clear:
The statement “Thick & dense collagen fibers in OSF function as regular
connective tissue similar to a tendon where the direction of collagen fiber
alignment occurs along the direction of stress” from an article by- Smitha
BR, Donoghue M. Clinical and histopathological evaluation of collagen fiber
orientation in patients with oral submucous fibrosis. J Oral Maxillofac Pathol
2011; 15: 154-60, is representing a specific fact as described by
authors in relation to behavior of thick and dense fibers in OSF. Theoretically, any
interested researcher could have found this fact. However, no other researcher
would have presented it in this particular manner using these exact words. This statement can, therefore, be
used by another author either by duplicating the statement and
placing it in a quotation mark as used above or by paraphrasing the sentence
while preserving its implications for e.g. Collagen fibers in OSF which are thick
& dense function in a manner similar to a tendon with the collagen fibers
aligning themselves along the direction of stress (Smitha BR and coauthor).
Remembering to paraphrase appropriately is only a small step towards a
plagiarism free publishing, yet it is certainly a start.
professional resources such as http://www.ithenticate.com/ are also very good tools for avoiding accidental plagiarism.
No comments:
Post a Comment